Three sisters impregnated by the same guy

14 year old Lilly, 16 year old Carly and 20 year old me all slept with my 25 year old boyfriend on the same night, and all of us got pregnant.

My name is Abby, I am 20 years old, and my 25 year old boyfriend, Wayne, had sex with me, my 16 year old sister, Carly, and my 14 year old sister, Lilly, all in the same night.

My sisters Carly and Lilly were spending the weekend with me at my studio flat, it was small, self-contained, basically the living room, bedroom and kitchen were all in the same room, the only separate room in there was the bathroom.

The day they arrived my boyfriend Wayne came over in the afternoon to meet them, and everything went great, they got on really well and my sisters liked him, we ordered pizza and drank a little bit of alcohol, a rare treat for my underage sisters who weren’t meant to be drinking, but it was fine at my place.

It got late and Wayne decided to spend the night, at around 1am in the morning we were getting tired so decided it was time to go to sleep, we all got in to our pyjamas, I opened up the sofa-bed and got in it, my sisters sleeping on a large inflatable mattress on the floor.

Wayne was the last out of the bathroom, the turned the light out and walked towards the sofa-bed, he had to walk passed my sisters, they both giggled seeing him in his boxer shorts, “Sweet dreams, girls.” He said as he stepped over them and got in to bed with me.

We stayed awake for a while and waited for my sisters to fall asleep, then we pulled the sheets over us, took off our clothes, and started fooling around, and within minutes we were having sex, I don’t know if it was the sound of me moaning, or the creaking of the sofa-bed, but something woke my sisters up and I heard them giggling.

I looked across and saw them watching what me and Wayne were doing, though they couldn’t see much because we had the covers over us, they were old enough to know what we were doing underneath them.

“Wayne…” I whispered, tapping him on the shoulder, “…we’re being watched.” I said.

Wayne turned his head and looked, he saw them and smiled, then looked back at me, “Let them watch.” He replied.

He continued fucking me while I bit my lip trying not to moan too loudly and looking at my sisters who were just staring at me and lightly giggling, and strangely it aroused me, and I had a stupid wild idea, I moved my head to the other side of Wayne’s and whispered to him, “Do you like my sisters? – Don’t look at them!” I said.

“Yes, why?” he asked.

“Would you fuck them?” I asked.

He looked at me surprised but intrigued, “Why are you asking me that?” he asked.

“Just answer the question. Would you?” I asked.

“Carly maybe.” He replied.

“Alright…” I said, then pushed on his stomach to force his cock out of me, “…hold on a minute.” I said.

“What are you doing?” he asked.

I reached down and found my nightshirt and put it back on, then I got out of bed, I took Carly’s hand and pulled her up off the mattress, “I need to talk to you.” I said, pulling her towards the bathroom.

“What did you drag me in here for?” she asked.

“Do you like Wayne?” I asked her.

“Yeah, he’s nice.” She replied.

“I’m going to ask you something, right, and if you don’t want to do it that’s okay, you can say no, and just forget I asked. Do you want to sleep with him?” I asked her.

“You mean sleep in your bed and you sleep on the mattress?” she asked.

“No, dumb ass. I mean do you want to fuck him?” I asked.

She looked shocked, “What do you mean?” she asked.

“I mean fuck him. Do you want to get in my bed with us and let him fuck you?” I Asked.

She blushed and smiled, “Does he want to fuck me?” she asked.

“Yes.” I said.

“I’ve never done it though.” She said.

“Don’t worry he’ll do everything, you just let him do it. So are you up for it?” I asked.

She nodded, “Okay. Yeah.” She replied.

“Come on then.” I said.

We left the bathroom, Carly was grinning and lightly giggling nervously as I held her hand and took her to my bed and we got under the covers with Wayne.

“Aren’t you sleeping on the floor?” asked Lilly, confused seeing Carly get in to my bed.

“Go to sleep, Lilly, love. We’re just talking.” I told her.

We waited a while for Lilly to go to sleep, she looked like she was drifting off but stayed awake watching us, we decided to ignore her and just do it, I told Carly to take her pyjama’s off under the covers, then I lifted the covers up and showed her Wayne’s cock.

We were all laid on our sides, me on the far left with my back to Lilly, Wayne in the middle facing Carly, and Carly on the far right facing Wayne, he put her hand on his cock and showed her how to jerk it, and he touched her and they kissed for a while.

Soon Carly was on her back and Wayne shuffled on top of her, her legs opened and I could see the lumps of her raised knees under the covers, she let out a sudden sharp moan when Wayne thrust his cock in to her pussy, “Uh-Argh.” I whispered to her to try and be quiet.

I gently massaged her breasts while Wayne fucked her, and it was so hot watching him fuck my sister and listening to their quiet moans of sexual pleasure.

“Ooh – Uh – Uh – Mm – Ungh – Oooah – Uh!”

Suddenly I heard Lilly’s voice right behind me, “Are you shagging?” she asked.

I looked back and she was standing right next to the bed, watching the covers go up and down seeing Wayne on top of Carly, “Lilly, you’re meant to be going to sleep.” I said.

“They’re shagging aren’t they?” she asked.

“Okay yes. Yes they are. Now, please go to sleep.” I said.

Wayne suddenly pushed the covers off, first with his hand, then kicked them off the bed with his legs, “Oh fuck it. Let her watch.” He said, having fully exposed himself and Carly on the bed, Lilly could see exactly what they were doing, seeing them both naked with Wayne bouncing up and down on top of Carly, “Uh – Uh – UH.”

Wayne then sat up and pulled Carly’s legs up against his front, resting them over his shoulders, and thrusting his cock in and out of her pussy, giving Lilly an unrestricted view of it all, and she stood by the bed in awe, eyes bulging, mouth open, just watching him fuck her sister.

He finished and came inside of Carly, his thrusting slowed as his balls drained in to her, “Ug - Oooaaagh – Oooagh!”

Then he pulled out and rolled on to his back, his still almost fully erect cock lying flat against his stomach, a bit of sperm oozing from the tip.

I leaned across, lifted his cock of his stomach and put it in to my mouth and sucked on it, getting the last drops and tasting my sisters pussy juice as well, “Mmm.” It was great.

“Eeew.” Groaned Lilly, watching me do it.

“It’s not ‘Eew’” Wayne said.

“Yeah it is.” Said Lilly.

“Why don’t you suck my cock and taste it for yourself, sweetheart.” Wayne said, giving her a wink.

I sat up and pulled Lilly on to the bed, then turned on the lamp next to the bed, I held both of her hands, “Lilly, darling, would you like to play with us?” I asked her.

She looked at Wayne and Carly, and then seemed very unsure, “You mean shagging?” she asked, with a giggle.

“Well, not necessarily, you don’t have to do that if you don’t want too.” I replied.

Then Wayne butted in for a moment, “Uhm – I haven’t agreed to that anyway.” He said.

“Shut up, Wayne.” I told him, then I told Lilly to look down at his cock, “How do you feel when you look at it?” I asked her.

She did a sort of icky facial expression then shrugged, “I don’t know.” She replied.

“It’s really good. Look…” I said, holding his cock again and lightly jerking it, then I leaned down and licked his tip, “…Just try it.” I said.

I eventually got her to touch it and hold it in her hand, she giggled a lot from nerves, and didn’t look too happy about it at first, but then I convinced her to lick it, she scrunched up her little face, “Salty.” She said, I made her keep licking it and eventually she put it in her mouth and sucked it, only about an inch in her mouth, but she sucked it.

Wayne’s cock became fully erect again, Lilly sat up and was enjoying stroking it, especially when Wayne gave her compliments and moaned occasionally, while she was sat up I moved around the bed behind her and I lifted her night shirt off her, she was almost flat chested still, Wayne smiled, “Nice nipples.” He said.

I put my arms around her, hugging her from behind, with my chin on the top of her head, “What do you think about shagging him, Lilly. Is that something you’d like to try?” I asked her.

She leaned to the side and turned her head to look at me, “Will it hurt?” she asked.

“It hurts a little – but not much.” Carly said to her.

“If you try it and it hurts too much, you can stop, we won’t force you to do it.” I said.

She thought about it, “Okay.” She said.

“Yeah? – You want to try it?” I asked for confirmation.

She nodded.

“How about it, Wayne. Want to fuck my baby sister?” I asked him.

“I’m game if she is.” He replied, enthusiastically.

I was fully aware of how old Lilly was and how small she was, so I didn’t want Wayne to go putting all his weight on her and just fucking her like crazy, so I told Lilly she could be on top of him instead, she would have full control of what happens, and she can stop at any time.

She took her panties off and revealed her little bald puffy pussy, “Mm.” Wayne hummed, liking what he saw between her legs.

He laid himself down on the middle of the bed, rubbing his cock to make it and keep it hard, I lifted Lilly up and sat her down on his upper legs, knees at either side of him, straddling him, his cock just in front of her.

“Okay, now, sit up on your knees…” I instructed, she sat up, then shuffled a bit forward until her pussy was hovering above the tip of his cock, then I held it straight for her, “…Slowly lower yourself down.” I said, she slowly went down and she stopped and flinched when she felt his warm tip press against her soft pussy, “Hold my hands.” She said, feeling a bit nervous and scared.

Carly sat up and we each held her hands to steady her.

She slowly pushed herself down, but of course she was a virgin and it would require a lot of pressure to penetrate her, we told her to push as hard as she could, but it kept hurting, she kept going from holding her breath to gasping rapidly, “Uh – Uh – Uh.”, then we told her to bounce, hammer the tip of his cock against her hymen, “Go on. You can do it.” I said.

Finally his cock broke through and she screamed, “Argh!” and stopped moving, “I can’t – I can’t” she gasped in a panic.

“It’s okay, it’s okay. Look at me. The hard part is over, that’s the most pain you’re going to feel now. You did it. Well done. But keep going – Be brave, okay.” I said.

She nodded.

“Good girl.” I said.

“You can do it, Lilly.” Said Carly.

She continued to lightly bounce, and every several minutes his cock slowly sank deeper inside her tight pussy, it was about 2-inches inside when she pulled her hands out of ours, then slammed them down on Wayne’s stomach, and she bounced like a little frog on his cock, “Uh – Uh – Uh.” I was impressed with her confidence.

“Go Lilly.” I cheered.

She giggled, gasping out moans, “Ungh – Uh – I’m doing it - Uh”

Wayne stretched his arms out and held on to her skinny waist and helped her to stay steady and bounce on him, “Oooh that’s great, Lilly – Oooh yeah.” He groaned.

She was doing really well but then got very tired very quickly and she had no energy left in her arms and legs, so Wayne rolled her over on to her back, now he was on top and continuing to fuck her, her little legs up in the air, her hands moving around the bed, grabbing at the sheets, her mouth wide open, moaning to the heavens with pleasure, “Ooooo – Uh – Uuuh – UUH!”

Wayne ejaculated inside of her, flooding her little pussy with his seed, “Ooooooooooooaaagh!” then pulled out of her and rolled on to his back, Carly and I sucked and licked his cock clean, tasting Lilly’s juices.

Lilly was crying but they were happy joyful tears, and we all had a good laugh and giggle about it before Wayne reminded me that we’d never finished, so he fucked me, and we continued to fool around through the night, each of us fucking Wayne at least twice.

After that weekend, a long weekend of amazing sex, my sisters went home happy and satisfied.

A few weeks later I got a call in the middle of the day from Carly, she was frantic, “I’m pregnant!” she said, crying on the phone to me, scared out of her mind, which came as a big shock to me because I had also just found out that I was pregnant.

I invited them both to come back that weekend and we sat and talked about it, Wayne said he would be there for both of us.

But the day after they arrived at my place, that morning, Lilly was throwing up in the bathroom, at first we thought it was just a bug or something but then we got worried when it happened again the next morning when they were due to go home, “You don’t think?” asked Carly.

“Oh god.” I said.

I got one of my unused pregnancy tests and Carly and I took Lilly in to the bathroom and get her to use it, and it turned out ‘Positive’ she too was pregnant, we were all pregnant by Wayne.

Carly is 16 and wouldn’t be too much of a big deal to tell our parents, but Lilly, she is still a kid, we have no idea how to explain that to our parents.

We still haven’t told them, and we’re all almost 3-months pregnant, we will start to show soon and we can’t put it down to being fat.

We’re so screwed.